roman-numerals-3Roman Numerals were a Numbering System that
Prevented an Entire Civilization from Doing Any Higher Math

By Thomas Frey, Executive Director and Senior Futurist at the DaVinci Institute

During the time of the ancient Greek civilization several mathematicians became famous for their work. People like Archimedes, Pythagoras, Euclid, Hipparchus, Posidonius and Ptolemy all brought new elements of thinking to society, furthering the field of math, building on the earlier work of Babylonian and Egyptian mathematicians

A few generations later the Romans became the dominant society on earth, and the one aspect of Roman society that was remarkably absent was the lack of Roman mathematicians. Rest assured, the scholarly members of Roman society came from a good gene pool and they were every bit as gifted and talented as the Greeks. But Roman society was being held hostage by its own systems. One of the primary culprit for the lack of Roman mathematicians was their numbering system – Roman Numerals and its lack of numeric positioningWhile its easy for us today to look at Roman numerals and say that it was a pretty stupid numbering system, it was just one of many inferior numbering systems in ancient times. But the feature that made Roman numerals so bad was the fact that each number lacked specific numeric positioning and was in fact an equation, and this extra layer of complexity prevented people from doing higher math.

Roman numerals were a system problem, and a huge one at that. They prevented an entire civilization from furthering the field of math and science

Roman society was so immersed in their numbering system that they had no clue that it was preventing them from doing even rudimentary math such as adding a column of numbers or simple multiplication or division, a feat still handled by abacus. It also prevented them from creating some of the more sophisticated banking and accounting systems and restricted academia from moving forward in areas of science, astronomy, and medicine.

Ratchet forward to today. We live in a society where virtually everything is different than the days of the Roman Empire. But what seems so counterintuitive to most is that we are even more dependent today on our systems than the Romans ever were. Most of these systems we take for granted – systems for weights and measurement, systems for accounting, banking, procurement, managing our traffic, and labeling our food. With each of these systems we are much like the Romans, immersed in the use of these systems to a point where we seldom step back and question the reasoning and logic behind them.

Our systems govern virtually every aspect of our lives. They determine how we live and where we live, what we eat and where we work, where and when we travel, how much money we will make, the job we do, the friends we have, who we marry, and even how long we will live. But much like fish not understanding what water is, we seldom step back to understand the context of our existence

As a starting point, one question we should be asking is “What systems do we employ today that are the equivalent of Roman numerals that are preventing us from doing great things?

This simple question is very revealing. It has a way of opening a Pandora’s box full of friction points, inefficiencies, and flow restrictors that we contend with every day. Our systems are what govern the flow of commerce, govern our effectiveness as members of society, and create much of the stress we face on a daily basis.

After studying American systems and applying this “equivalency to Roman numerals” test, it is easy to conclude that we are only operating at somewhere between 5-10% efficiency, maybe less. The upside is huge

So what are some examples of restrictive systems that are preventing us from doing great things? Here are just a few examples:

  • Income Tax System – The income tax system is currently the mother of all boat anchors, slowing commerce and the pace of business to a crawl. Currently somewhere in the neighborhood of 64,000 pages in length, the US tax code that we use today will stand as a shining example throughout history as one of the world’s most incomprehensible systems of all times.
  • Half-Implemented Metric System – America is well-known for its a half-implemented metric system where people are purchasing cars with 3.2 liter engines and filling them with quarts of oil. Several well-known disasters have been attributed to the engineering complexities involved in converting between English and Metric.
  • Keyboards – Stemming from the days of mechanical typewriters with typebars that fast typers found easy to jam, we still use the keyboards that were designed to slow the speed of typers by placing the most frequently used keys randomly across the face of the keyboard. But keyboards in any configuration are an extremely inefficient way to transfer knowledge from one person to another.
  • Laws – We now have more laws on the books in the US than any country at any time in history. There aren’t even any good estimates as to the number of laws on the books in the US. With each city, county, state, federal agency, and taxing district able to issue their own regulations, mandates, ordinances, and laws, we have created a legal snake pit of intertwined and overlapping rules that we are expected to live by

Lest you think the US is the only country with system problems, consider some of the major issues plaguing other countries:

  • Chinese Alphabet – The number of Chinese characters contained in the Kangxi dictionary is approximately 47,035, although a large number of these are rarely-used variants accumulated over time. Studies carried out in China have shown that full literacy requires a knowledge of between three and four thousand characters.
  • Languages in India – The country of India has a diverse number of languages spoken by the different groups of people. At least 800 different languages and around 2,000 dialects have been identified. The Constitution of India has mandated that Hindi and English be the official two languages of communication for the Central government. However, each of India’s state governments are free to name their own official language.
  • Currencies in Japan – Japan has become the global laboratory for experimental and complementary currencies with the number of officially sanctioned currencies now exceeding 600.

Much like the rest of the world, we are a long ways from optimizing the systems that govern our lives. Inefficiencies have become a way of life with most people resigned to “leave well enough alone”.

But the freedom that we value so highly in the US is only a fraction of what it can be. Our ability to confront and deal with some of the big problems ahead is highly dependent upon our ability to seriously reinvent society,,,,, one system at a time.

5 Responses to “Lessons from the Ancient World”

Comments List

  1. <a href='http://daisy.yourstoriessite.com/whoishipparchus.html' rel='external nofollow' class='url'>who is hipparchus</a>

    [...] Futurist at the DaVinci Institute During the time of the ancient Greek civilization several mathemahttp://www.futuristspeaker.com/2008/04/lessons-from-the-ancient-world/Hipparchus - definition of Hipparchus by the Free Online ...Definition of com in the Online [...]
  2. bobbyhill

    thanks this really helped me with my roman numeral project i have.:) My teacher gives them to us like every week. It a little difficult keeping up but 3 weeks till schools out so this will probrably be the last one because of finals then we are free for 2 months
  3. <a href='http://www.eyeoftheraaven.blogspot.com' rel='external nofollow' class='url'>cantubury</a>

    Maybe the Romans had the numeral system maintained to restrain growth, invention and innovation.Latin was used and died, except for what other languages used for beginnings and endings etymology. Math seems to be the magical key to understanding why goldfish have a 3 second memory and strings vibrate butterfly wings causing global destruction from thousands of miles away and the sun reverses its magnetic poles and causes sunspots disabling our satellites. Scientific discovery is the why and math seems to be the how. The Greeks also taxed the citizens to death, opened endless wars and entertained the people with "circuses and bread"-free grain, and in our case TV. It kept people happy while the government went on with no controls. Could we be on that path by not making education free and teaching free thinking skills? you decide
  4. <a href='http://www.metricationmatters.com' rel='external nofollow' class='url'>Pat Naughtin</a>

    Dear Thomas Frey, You wrote about the half-implemented metric system. You might be interested in this article: http://www.metricationmatters.com/docs/CostOfNonMetrication.pdf Cheers, Pat Naughtin Geelong. Australia P.S. Your reference to the 'half-implemented metric system' probably understates the real position. Try not using the metric system at all; you could use this article to get you started: http://www.metricationmatters.com/docs/DontUseMetric.pdf
  5. <a href='http://bhaarat.org' rel='external nofollow' class='url'>Bhaarat</a>

    The article talks the limitation of the Roman numerals but in no way explores where the solution came from and why. The decimal place value number system is a gift of the Indian civilization and is a result of abstract thinking and philosophical leap taken by ancient Indians. Also its funny that the author sees 800 languages in India as an issue. Diversity of thought and expression is a gift for societies. Homogenous cultures speaking a single language are like sterile ecosystems that become stagnant and non-creative.

Leave a Reply